Trans Equality Society of Alberta
  • About
    • Land & Indigenous Peoples' Acknowledgement
    • TESA Bylaws
  • Newsroom
    • Advocates push for gender surgery funding within Alberta amid years-long backlog in Montreal​
    • TESA responds to anti-trans protests at Calgary pool
    • TESA responds to the People's Party of Canada Statement
    • No One Right Is More Important Than Another: TESA Op-ed
    • TESA responds to the upcoming debate of Bill 207: Conscience Rights (Health Care Providers) Protection Act
    • TESA on Bill 207 Presentation to the Legislative Assembly of Alberta Committee on Private Bills & Private Members' Public Bills
    • TESA acknowledges the 20th Anniversary of TDOR
    • TESA on the 20th Anniversary of TDOR - CTV Morning Live Edmonton
    • TESA on Bill 207 - Alberta Primetime
    • TESA on Bill 207 - Ryan Jesperson Show
    • TESA on Bill 207 - Global Edmonton Interview
    • TESA on Bill 207 - CBC Interview
    • TESA responds to tabling of Bill 207: Conscience Rights (Health Care Providers) Protection Act
    • TESA supports federal trans rights bill
    • Alberta sees increased trans visibility
    • Alberta clarifies trans inclusion
    • TESA supports AHRA enumeration
    • Alberta to raise flag for TDOR
    • Students families staff need explicit inclusion
    • Trans pride flag raising a first for Alberta
    • Alberta capital proclaims TDOV
    • AB enumerates gender identity and expression
    • Federal equality campaign
    • Condemn trans segregation amendment
    • Hopeful ID rules signal positive change
    • Known issues ignored
    • Bill C-36 magnifies trans danger
    • Object to current VSA amendment
    • Support for birth reg reform
    • Inaugural State of Trans report
    • Second inclusive school board
    • Cities of Calgary and Edmonton support
    • Bill C-279 passes
    • Response to GRS relisting
    • Airline regulation change
    • Inclusive schools policy
    • Bill C-389 dies
    • Transsexuals not consulted
    • Funding cut review request
    • New Alberta trans group
  • Letters & Statements
    • TESA Congratulates Desjarlais and Boissonnault in their Election Victories
    • TESA Motions for Concurrence – Bill 207 Letter to Premier Kenney
    • TESA on Bill 207 Presentation to the Legislative Assembly of Alberta Committee on Private Bills & Private Members' Public Bills
    • TESA letter to the Standing Committee Members on Private Bills and Private Members' Public Bills
    • TESA's statement for the Stop Bill 207! Rally
    • TESA Against Conscience Rights Bill Letter to Premier Kenney
    • Amend AHRA
    • Registration reform
    • Accessing Canadian passports
    • Specialist accessibility
    • Outstanding concerns
    • Accessing routine healthcare
  • Membership
  • Bookmarks
  • Donate
  • Campaigns
    • NOTtrashrights
  • Reports
    • An Allys view on GSAs
    • State of Trans Report >
      • STA:TDOV 2014
    • LCJC2014-C279
    • AB Human Services 2014
    • RIDR2013
    • JUST2012
    • TRAN2012
  • Resources
    • Fact Pages >
      • Alberta Identity Documents
      • GRS funding in Alberta
      • Human rights across Canada
      • School inclusion in Alberta
      • Trans Patient Care Guide For health care professionals
    • Simplified air travel chart
    • Archives >
      • Alberta GRS funding
      • Canadian law
      • School Inclusion
      • NOTtrashrightscampaign
  • Links
    • Organisations >
      • Trans Organisations
      • Professional Associations
    • Transitioning >
      • About Trans & Transitioning
      • About Two Spirit
      • About Non Binary
      • Medical Resources
      • Identity Documents
      • Employment Resources
    • Legal >
      • Legal Cases
      • Legal Analyses
      • Human Rights Resources
      • Immigration & Asylum
      • Violence Resources
      • Public Accommodations
      • Bereavement Resources
    • Institutions >
      • Education Resources
      • Shelter Resources
      • Military Resources
      • Policing Resources
      • Incarceration Resources
    • Culture >
      • Observances
      • History
      • Media Resources
  • Contact
  • New Page

REVISED: TESA condemns federal trans-exclusionary amendment to Bill C-279


**NOTE: An earlier version of this media release incorrectly identified the amendment's supporters as being five Conservative and one Liberal Senator. The amendment was supported exclusively by Conservative Senators.

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE--February 26, 2015--ALBERTA, CANADA


The Trans Equality Society of Alberta (TESA) condemns the discriminatory amendments to trans* rights' Bill C-279 brought this week by Senator Don Plett at a meeting of the Canadian Senate standing committee on Legal and Constitutional Affairs.

"Bill C-279 has been poisoned," says TESA president Jan Buterman. "If the now-amended bill were to pass into law, Canada would officially institute national segregation of trans* citizens."

Bill C-279 was tabled in parliament to add the phrase "gender identity" to the Canadian Human Rights Act and the Criminal Code. Experts have testified that trans* people are already covered by existing legislation and the Charter, but that clarifying protections for trans* people would be helpful.

On Wednesday, the Senate standing committee voted to add an amendment to the bill that would enshrine exclusion of trans* people from places such as federal washrooms or change rooms, a move that explicitly denies trans* equality. By calling for complete segregation of trans women--trans men were ignored as harmless, in his opinion--from gendered spaces, Senator Plett is engaging in the very sort of discrimination the bill was originally intended to prevent.

The bill's sponsor in the Senate, Senator Grant Mitchell (Liberal), said, “The very act that is designed to prohibit discrimination is being amended to allow discrimination.”

**Distressingly, a majority of the senators on the Legal and Constitutional Affairs committee voted in favour of this amendment, with six Conservative senators voting for, four Liberal senators against. Senator Mobina Jaffer (Liberal) stated, "This is discriminatory. We are trying to take away the discrimination and then we are putting back the discrimination."**

Amendments were expected from Conservative senators as a means of delaying the bill by returning it to Parliament, a process that would slow the bill's passage enough to be killed completely by the upcoming federal election.

"TESA did not expect the nature of those amendments," says Buterman. "Who would expect a committee charged with studying Canada's laws and our constitution to attempt to enshrine overtly discriminatory practises into federal law? Who would expect that any jurisdiction in North America would seriously propose to insist some people may not use government facilities?"

During discussions, other committee members pointed out that at the provincial level--where five [sic] provinces already have trans protections in place--there has never been an incident of the type so feared by Senator Plett. In the absence of evidence of such threats, an amendment serves no purpose other than to further segregation of an already vulnerable population. This position was affirmed by Senator Jaffer who stated, "Assuming that the transgender person is a threat, I have great difficulty with this."

Senator Plett did not explain how--if enacted--this amendment was to be enforced. Other than prisons, where individuals can be forced to completely disrobe, it's unclear as to just how inspections for an individual's birth sex is to be accomplished. Despite Senator Mitchell also trying to clarify that this amendment would force fully-transitioned trans men--potentially with large muscles, full beards, deep voices, and male clothing--into using women's spaces, ultimately Senators Plett, Batters, Manning, Dagenais, McInnis, and McIntyre voted in favour of adopting the amendment.

"TESA is concerned that such legislation would increase vigilante actions against trans and gender-non-conforming persons, as this is exactly the scenario that has led to high profile, violent incidents against trans* persons in the past," says Buterman. "Declaring some Canadians to be less-than other Canadians cannot possibly serve our nation well. All Canadians share equality rights, so for senators to attempt to enshrine segregation in our laws must be rejected as incompatible with that equality."


For further information, please see:

TESA -- Including the term Gender Identity in Canadian Statutes: Bill C-279
http://www.tesaonline.org/lcjc2014-c279.html

TESA -- Human Rights Across Canada
http://www.tesaonline.org/human-rights-across-canada.html


CAN -- Charter of Rights and Freedoms
http://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/const/page-15.html

CAN -- Canadian Human Rights Act
http://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/acts/h-6/page-1.html#he

CAN -- Criminal Code
http://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/acts/c-46


CHRC -- Protect rights of transgender people: testimony of Ian Fine, Canadian Human Rights Commission to Senate standing committee on Justice and Human Rights regarding Bill C-279 (2012, November 22)
http://www.chrc-ccdp.ca/eng/content/protect-rights-transgender-people

CHRC -- Chief commissioner speaks on the inclusion of Gender Identity as a ground of discrimination: testimony of David Langtry, Canadian Human Rights Commission to Senate standing committee on Justice and Human Rights regarding Bill C-279 (2013, June 3)
http://www.chrc-ccdp.gc.ca/eng/content/chief-commissioner-speaks-inclusion-gender-identity-ground-discrimination


ARTICLE -- 15 Experts Debunk Right-Wing Transgender Bathroom Myth (Brinker & Maza, 2014)
http://mediamatters.org/research/2014/03/20/15-experts-debunk-right-wing-transgender-bathro/198533

ARTICLE -- An inconvenient booth: mistaking symbol for both map and territory (Buterman, 2013)
http://www.thefreelibrary.com/AN+inconvenient+booth%3A+mistaking+symbol+for+both+map+and+territory.-a0366804191


More information about TESA can be found at www.tesaonline.org


-- 30 --


back to Newsroom  |  back to About

TRANS EQUALITY SOCIETY of ALBERTA  |  PO Box 2053 Edmonton Main  |  Edmonton  |  Alberta  |  T5J 2P4